I changed my blog title from homeschooling to education

I always feel like a responsible world citizen when I read an article from Al-Jazeera. I know whatever I read from there will come from a writer who has a different perspective on the world than the majority of writers who I read.
So I was happy when someone sent me an article from there about homeschooling. I was surprised that Al Jazeera would cover the topic. But then I saw they have an education section.
That was the nail in the coffin for me calling this section of my blog homeschooling. I decided to change it to education. Because in order for anyone to make sense of homeschooling they have think about education in a much more broad sense.
That change had to wait for a pause in the Ukrainian revolution because my web developer lives in the thick of it.
And the education moniker fits into the rest of my Penelope Trunk gestalt as well, because it’s nearly impossible to talk about careers and not talk about education. An effective career path is actually an effective learning path. Separate the two and your career will fail.
This article by Marc Prensky will be an interesting read for all parents and teachers but especially homeschooling parents. It makes a compelling case against the common core but from a different take than usual: Education isn’t preparing our children with the skills they need for success in the 21st century. Prensky makes a case for a brand new curriculum. It is one that many homeschoolers who lean more toward the unschooling do naturally. He also has an interesting take on technology and how education is an extension of our brains and that is a good thing.
But this is starting to feel like old news to me. Like, the only reason people have to keep writing stuff like this is because schools are in no position to act on it. Increasinlgly I’m seeing that school-reform advocates largely say the same thing , and schools largely ignore it.
So I am not sure there’s a point in saying things more clearly. We can’t change school. It’s a national babysitting service, and we could never afford to provide that in a more innovative way. We can barely afford to improve it as a semi-jail. So we have no room to do reform until we stop thinking of education as babysitting. And that’s not going to happen because parents would not be able to go to work. It’s just really such a fundamental problem.
Careers are about education because fulfilling work is about self-directed personal growth. Education should also be about self-directed persona growth, yet we are forced to learn how to educate ourselves in the workplace since we don’t have a chance to self-direct our personal growth in school.
Also, education and careers are heavily influenced by the shifting of our idea of what constitutes a family. The current system for both education and careers stems from an extreme devaluing of family in our society. Homeschooling is a moderate response to this extreme.
And it feels right that my web site has the topics of careers, education, courses and one-on-one coaching. Because we are all learning to make these big changes together.

“We can’t change school… [R]eform… [is] … not going to happen because parents would not be able to go to work.”
Fundamental problem, indeed. You have come to this conclusion relatively quickly in your journey. Good for you! It took me a few years. Your opportunity (responsibility?) to voice your opinions just turned up a notch. ;)
I always feel a little ‘prick’ in my arm whenever you bash traditional education. May I say ‘ouch!’
I would appreciate a fairer perspective on it as well as I’d like to see people share a fairer perspective on home education.
Every system set up by humans will have cracks and flaws- that’s our nature. Our nature also includes a willingness to try and make the systems we create better. As underfunded and neglected as many public school districts are I have personally met many teachers who actively work diligently to provide a competitive education and positive environment for the students in their care.
When my little one brings home the work I’ve seen she’s done and reports on her growing socializing skills (an introvert, by definition), I can not help but feel like the public school system she thrives in is very unlike the one you’ve experienced. But, I know, all experiences are different.
I’ve experienced the good and bad within the public school system myself. I like that there are alternatives (i.e. home school, montessori, etc.)- there should be. But again, within each of those systems there are bound to be flaws as I’ve witnessed in all three.
That said, please try to refrain from describing my child’s educational experience as a stone’s throw from a Dicken’s novel or Pink Floyd concept album. :-) Every experience is likely to be different.
Oh, and by the way, I have to call you out on event dropping (“web developer in Ukraine”). That’s like me mentioning the time I saw Chevy Chase eat an apple on set and the time my friend’s went to the Pink Floyd concert- in Berlin when the wall fell. I don’t recall them mentioning David Hasselhoff but from what I hear, he stole the show.
@ Chris M – read a different blog, this one clearly does not meet your needs.
@ Penelope – don’t change a thing. I appreciate your perspective.
@Frank
I respectfully disagree with Mrs. Trunk on a couple of points here and there and that’s simply because the experience I’ve had and have seen has never been as terrible as the one she describes. I’ve had my share of apathetic, bored and uninspired teachers. I’ve certainly questioned the validity of testing as a weeding out process rather than a tool for feedback and enhancement. I’ve even questioned the voracity (or lack of) in the material I’ve been offered. I clearly stated that I’m glad alternatives to traditional education are gaining ground because I believe different people have different educational needs and respond to different methods. These ideas have been supported by Mrs. Trunk in several other posts. Again, I just disagree that one system is worse than another.
As for my needs and a blog, that’s a fascinating assessment. I believe people can disagree on topics and still share valuable ideas. Disagreement is not the end of the world or the end of someone’s value to one another. Feel free to disagree. :-)
Yes, that’s a smug smirk but at least I didn’t stick my tongue out.
:-p
Oops! There it is.
The point is that it is incredibly rude to come to someone’s blog and try and tell them what they should and should not write about because it bothers you when she bashes public schools. You are more than free to disagree with her but that does not include instructing her on how to present the content of her arguments.
@Chris M
By every measurable educational and social objective your child’s traditional education is demonstrably inferior. It may hurt to read but it is none the less true. There might be reasons to continue with an inferior system. But no matter how many or how good the reasons may be, the reasons don’t make the education better, even if they make readers feel better.
@Queen
There isn’t much that disturbs or surprises me about people in this world anymore aside from people 100% certain of anything.
‘demonstrably inferior’, where’s your data? How many articles are you citing? What are the outliers on the data and how was the criteria for this research you’re citing formulated?
And then, if we’re demonstrating, are you arguing environment over innate ability? Can you replicate all the variables in any two student experiences to draw reliable, repeatable conclusions? Have any of the variables your basing your statement on changed over time?
I am humbled daily by what I don’t know. I can appreciate someone who has all the answers which I lack. As for social sciences comparing as a science in the likes of physics, part of me wants to chuckle at the thought but I don’t want to come off as ‘smug’. As for anyone standing on a good mass of social science data, I’d suggest they stand on very weak ground. As for anyone who swears by a handful of internet studies with no data, well, hmmm….
I think it’s too late to not sound smug- sorry. :-/